Monday, March 20, 2000
Jakob the Liar / ** (1999)
The ironic thing behind "Jakob The Liar" is that the film is so appropriately titled; its plot is a charade of tearjerker situations, sentiment, and the thickest of melodrama. Robin Williams even seems to be uncomfortable with the material (which may be surprising, since he has been in sappy junk like "Patch Adams" and "Dead Poets Society" throughout his career). He stares at the characters around him and shouts out dialogue without much grace or style; perhaps he is simply struggling to remember the exact words. Either way, he and the audience are trapped in one of the biggest farces of the past year--a movie so self-centered and unbelievably obvious that it actually thinks there is something left to be said about the holocaust.
Never mind that Roberto Benigni’s "Life Is Beautiful," a brilliant achievement, has covered all the necessary ground (despite the fact that it was shot after "Jakob The Liar" was nearing completion). This film's story takes place in Poland during the outbreak of World War II. Jakob Heym is a Jewish cafe owner who, while in Nazi headquarters for staying out past ghetto curfew, overhears on a radio that Russian soldiers are moving in, and Germany's power in the war is fading fast. He shares this news with his close friend, who spreads the word faster than anyone could imagine. Soon everyone in the ghetto assumes that Jakob has his own radio, and can listen in on the late-breaking reports that are sent through the radio waves. Since he's already done the damage and built up their hope, though, he plays along with their little assumption; throughout the movie we see him contriving all sorts of faux information regarding the war, just to sustain their dreams. But what would have happened her if the Germans beat out the Russians and regained their power? What if his entire ghetto was put to death? Heym would have lied for nothing.
"Jakob The Liar" is a droll, endless exercise in the manipulation of emotion, and because it draws inspiration from actual events, we have all the more reason to dislike it. One of the positive qualities of "Life Is Beautiful" was its ability to give characters a ray of hope even when situations were harsh. This movie has no compassion--the material is incredibly fake, lacking heart, spirit, and a general reward. All 120 minutes are told without a heartfelt desire; Jakob continues to build hope for his ghetto, even though his lies could prove deadly and the Germans regain their power in the war. He and the director are taking too many risks here. The only difference? Jakob gets away with them.
Written by DAVID KEYES
Drama (US); 1999; Rated PG-13; 120 Minutes
Robin Williams: Jakob Heym
Hannah Taylor-Gordon: Lina Kronstein
Éva Igó: Lina's Mother
István Bálint: Lina's Father
Justus von Dohnany: Preuss
Kathleen Gati: Hooker
Produced by Nick Gillott, Steven Haft, Lew Rywin, Marsha Garces Williams and Robin Williams; Directed by Peter Kassovitz; Screenwritten by Peter Kassovitz and Didier Decoin; based on the novel by Jurek Becker